Original Post|Amelia Arman
Do you really know what your child is experiencing in daycare?
For many American families, daycare is a trusted option for childcare while both parents of the household work to provide for the needs of the family. These families feel as though their children are being properly cared for and nurtured by the daycare staff. However, these daycares can cause physical or emotional stress in their child. A child’s perceived stress is best defined as either an actual or imagined threat that is personal and overwhelming to the point that emotional, psychological, developmental, and/or physiological changes are observed in the child’s behavior (Davis, 2023). Sadly, there are many low-quality daycares that cause stress in children under the age of six. These low-quality daycares lack caregiver response and can damage the emotional well-being of the child or infant in their care through abuse and/or neglect. In a 2023 study of mostly American children, results revealed that the quality of early childhood education and quality of care impacts children’s early childhood development (Suchodoletz, 2023).
Harms of Low-Quality Daycare Centers
Low-quality daycare centers are usually run by harsh or neglectful employees who either lack the experience of caring for the child’s emotional wellbeing, or who do not show signs of caring for one reason or another. These daycare workers are often underpaid, overworked, burnt out and desensitized to children’s cries. They tend to not feel compelled to attentively care for the needs of the children in their care, which can lead to neglect, causing stress in the child. There are also cases in which young children are preyed upon by caregivers, who purposely insert themselves into an environment to be able to target young children. Many of these children become victims of sexual and physical abuse. Children are an easy target for these predators because they are impressionable and vulnerable to manipulation. Specifically, infants are non-verbal and unable to vocalize their trauma. To a predator, these young children are the perfect targets.
How do you know what to look for when attempting to choose a high-quality daycare for your child?
Researching the daycare center and reviewing their licensing information is important before deciding to enroll your child in a specific daycare. Some daycare options, such as in-home daycares, give you the option to place your child in the home of a caregiver who is not licensed. A licensed daycare is one in which the state has inspected and approved the home and has completed a background check on the caregiver. Licensing for childcare is also based on certain health and safety standards. This does not ensure that the child will be in a stress-free environment but knowing that your chosen daycare is licensed at least provides some comfort in that the child will be in an environment that has been through inspection and that the staff has been properly screened. Speaking with parents who have either enrolled their children in daycare or currently have a child enrolled is also important as they can provide insight into their experience and insight into the type of care their children received or are receiving in that particular daycare center. Parents can also ask the daycare center that they are considering if its workers have been through screening and what type of screening the daycare center uses. For example, modern times have provided a machine learning approach to identifying non-parental caregivers’ risk for harsh caregiving towards infants in daycare centers. A 2023 study was able to identify a set of indicators and predictive rules that could accurately predict women’s risk for harsh caregiving behavior in daycare environments. This machine learning approach can be used as a screening tool to predict harsh caregiver behavior in women from 100% chance to report low levels of harsh caregiving behavior with a 95.2% accuracy. This allows the daycare center to decline employment to anyone who scores low in the chance of not exemplifying harsh caregiving behavior (Sharon, 2024).
What are the long-term psychological effects of low-quality daycare abuse on children?
An alarming finding is that, for most children, the parent and caregiver relationships are interchangeable in terms of attachment figures. Therefore, daycare abuse or neglect should be considered a subsidiary attachment trauma, which is a form of relational trauma involving impairments in the healthy bonding between the child and their secondary caregivers. These abuses within the daycare setting have been implicated in emotional posttraumatic manifestations, such as difficulty in processing emotional depression and anxiety and tendencies towards aggressive behavior. In addition, children who were victims of sexual abuse exhibited symptoms of post traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) with 30% of the children having sexual behavior problems, 25% internalizing problems, 17% attachment insecurity, and 18% other psychiatric disorders. These children also showed problems concerning emotions and toilet training. The long-term effects of this abuse were found to be that 5-10 years after the abuse, over one-third of the children remained clinically symptomatic (Talmon, 2023).
What are the alternatives?
Infants and toddlers who are placed in high-quality daycare settings have shown improved psychosocial skills and cognitive development. In a study that included sixty-eight infants and toddlers in daycare and sixty-eight infants and toddlers not in daycare with an almost equal male to female ratio, it was found that the infants and toddlers who attended high-quality daycare with caring, attentive caregivers had increased levels of psychosocial, cognitive, motor, and language development compared to those who did not attend high-quality daycare. Of the infants and toddlers who attended high quality daycare, 100% showed normal levels of psychosocial, cognitive, motor, and language development while only 77.9% of those not attending a high-quality daycare showed normal levels of psychosocial development, 69.1% showed normal levels of cognitive development, 75% showed normal levels of motor development, and 79.4% showed normal levels of language development (Villarreal-RĂos, 2021).
Conclusion
All of these findings suggest that high-quality daycares can be beneficial to the growth and development of children. Not all daycares produce negative effects on children. Parents just need to be vigilant about their research of daycares and find care that improves their child’s development rather than causing stress, which can hinder their emotional development over a long period of time. Take the time to get to know the center and the people who will be caring for your child. Know what is happening in your child’s daycare class and the other parents will also aid you in making sure that, long-term, you made the right choice for the emotional wellbeing of your child.
Author
My name is Amelia Arman and I am a Psychology major at Franciscan Missionaries of Our Lady University with the goal to become a child and family counselor. I am very interested in the way that children emotionally develop and the long term effects that childhood experiences can have on their development. I chose this topic because, as a long-term babysitter, I have seen the negative effects that low-quality daycare can have on the emotional development of young children, and would like to help guide parents in choosing whether or not daycare is the best option for them and in choosing the best daycare setting for their individual child.
References
Davis, S. L., & Soistmann, H. C. (2022). Child’s perceived stress: A concept analysis. Journal of pediatric nursing. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10167593/. dio not found
Sharon, C., & Rousseau, S. (2024). A machine learning approach to identifying non-parental caregivers' risk for harsh caregiving towards infants in daycare centers. Early Childhood Research Quarterly, 67, 128-138. dio not found https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0885200623001692
Talmon, A., Ditzer, J., Talmon, A., & Tsur, N. (2024, January). Maltreatment in daycare settings: A review of empirical studies in the field. Trauma, violence & abuse. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10666466/. doi not found
Villarreal-RĂos, E., Cruz-HernĂ¡ndez, C., Morales-Morales, K., Vargas-Daza, E. R., Galicia-RodrĂguez, L., Isassi-GonzĂ¡lez, D. M., & GuzmĂ¡n-Padilla, E. (2021). Comparison of growth and psychomotor development in daycare centers attended by professionals. BoletĂn MĂ©dico del Hospital Infantil de MĂ©xico. https://www.bmhim.com/frame_esp.php?id=277. doi: 10.24875/BMHIM.21000068
von Suchodoletz A;Lee DS;Henry J;Tamang S;Premachandra B;Yoshikawa H;, A., Lee, S. D., Henry, J., Tamang , S., Premachandra, B., & Yoshikawa, H. (n.d.). Early childhood education and care quality and associations with child outcomes: A meta-analysis. PloS one. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/37228090/. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0285985

